Most sites make one star the worst score you can give. We start at zero, because sometimes a book and a reader simply do not get on, and that is worth saying plainly.
The scale
- 5 stars: couldn't put it down. You missed your stop. You told a stranger about it.
- 4 stars: really good. Glad you read it, and you would lend it to a friend.
- 3 stars: good. Solid. It did the job.
- 2 stars: it was okay. It had its moments, and you won't think about it again.
- 1 star: not for me. You finished it out of stubbornness.
- 0 stars: couldn't finish it. The bookmark never got past chapter three.
House rules
- One review per person per title. Changed your mind? Post again and the new review replaces the old one.
- Review the book, not the other reviewers.
- Giving away the ending? Say so in your first line.
- You can't review something you uploaded yourself.
A zero is not an insult. It is information, and the next reader will thank you for it.
Posted by The Cliffhanger desk on 7 November 2026
Conversation 2
Want to join in? Sign in Join free
Jonas B.
Does a zero count towards the average?
The Cliffhanger desk
It does. A zero pulls the average down like any other score.